{
  "state": "VISUAL_REVIEW_COMPLETE",
  "reviewer": "ASTRA_WORKER_1",
  "scope": "Qualitative comparison of existing outputs; no tracker/SAM/neural inference, fitted metric or physical-contact scoring",
  "viewed": [
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/review/assets/lamp/rw_2026092501_all_frames.png",
      "sha256": "af330c19791e7039048a9301f3ed478ab173d72558c2d8df80f1c6fcfc21b8fc",
      "method": "Actual image-reading tool; full sequential frame sheet, not a video playback perception score"
    },
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/review/assets/lamp/rw_2026092502_all_frames.png",
      "sha256": "a340fc8348724d0b0137c8b1820dc7b03262bbf8469b7ece6aa152468e0e6279",
      "method": "Actual image-reading tool; full sequential frame sheet, not a video playback perception score"
    },
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/review/assets/lamp/bridge_all_frames.png",
      "sha256": "98c57ac712323a548394892778da3582efe3fc2591459676fd41f33519c9cbfe",
      "method": "Actual image-reading tool; full sequential frame sheet, not a video playback perception score"
    },
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/review/assets/persimmon/rw_2026092501_all_frames.png",
      "sha256": "bbd8b16f5c79fe5def369bd52d144ce3938fe5e60a98e733d7d094fc04bb94ce",
      "method": "Actual image-reading tool; full sequential frame sheet, not a video playback perception score"
    },
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/review/assets/persimmon/rw_2026092502_all_frames.png",
      "sha256": "9e5e048846ef8278400eba083a04f377225afcaa3e87574e0377f7c07e27b6b1",
      "method": "Actual image-reading tool; full sequential frame sheet, not a video playback perception score"
    },
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/review/assets/persimmon/bridge_all_frames.png",
      "sha256": "d6c6e6d7e44844ad66912da48b082ff132331390b095b88c5ce742bd033a09fd",
      "method": "Actual image-reading tool; full sequential frame sheet, not a video playback perception score"
    },
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/figures/figure_01_lamp_pipeline.png",
      "sha256": "de2334003de3d2920b022ca47d34505cecd3b7a07c70f6502bad4a11e745d722",
      "method": "Actual image-reading tool; checked content, labels and layout"
    },
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/figures/figure_02_geometry_and_initialization.png",
      "sha256": "7fa924a194c349d093caea6cecb0977307e406995c492f1ce1b843539ffd51dd",
      "method": "Actual image-reading tool; checked content, labels and layout"
    },
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/figures/figure_03_persimmon_limits.png",
      "sha256": "7dd0fc221307410941779330e863a12d5bc8948de985b71debd3c7095134b22e",
      "method": "Actual image-reading tool; checked content, labels and layout"
    },
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/figures/figure_04_condition_contract.png",
      "sha256": "4733f02b4403ea96a2e56bf3590ca818b727010ee9ba681bf1b458f91e930a5a",
      "method": "Actual image-reading tool; checked content, labels and layout"
    }
  ],
  "native_frames_in_sheets": 324,
  "bridge_frames_in_sheets": 50,
  "additional_large_native_frames_per_scene": [
    0,
    40,
    80
  ],
  "observations": {
    "lamp": [
      "The primary and secondary native frame sequences show rightward lamp movement with the box/base and floral pattern retained. The primary reaches the right edge late; exact motion is not scored.",
      "The bridge also moves right, but changes the dark bank/water/background, brightens the lamp and loses the floral pattern. The first generated frame differs from the reference.",
      "The full saved mesh is visibly uneven and complete; its watertight topology does not validate unseen shape. The actual collision body is a box, and the pictured water is not a simulated fluid.",
      "The bridge source object touches no frame edge in 25 frames; output completeness and hidden contact remain unqualified."
    ],
    "persimmon": [
      "Both native seeds show upper-object separation, rightward movement of the top fruit, left/down movement of the middle fruit, and late overlap at the bottom boundary.",
      "The bridge shows the same broad separation/fall pattern, while changing gloss, lobed contours, leaves and the table/horizon. Frame-zero appearance is already different.",
      "The source-camera crop truncates the bottom fruit initially; boundary touches for objects0/1/2 are19/25,20/25,25/25. Both routes inherit limited visible support. Complete-object integrity and contact cannot be adjudicated.",
      "The saved source render exposes texture/surface holes during rotation, despite watertight OBJ meshes. Generated fills are not demonstrated geometry recovery."
    ]
  },
  "limitations": [
    "Contact-sheet inspection does not establish exact dynamics or motion-perception equivalence.",
    "Source-bound timestamps do not certify that generated RGB follows those states."
  ],
  "selection": "Lowest recorded native seed frozen before output inspection; second existing seed retained; no generated-quality selection",
  "browser_screenshots_inspected": [
    "browser_overview.png",
    "browser_lamp_outputs.png",
    "browser_persimmon_outputs.png",
    "browser_geometry.png",
    "browser_mobile.png"
  ],
  "browser_observation": "Final desktop/mobile screenshots and both paused final-video panels were inspected with the image-reading tool. Both videos visibly rendered after exact seeks; the two route panels are aligned. The full-mesh interactive lamp view rendered with bundled Plotly using CPU software WebGL.",
  "browser_screenshots": [
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/logs/browser_overview.png",
      "relative_path": "logs/browser_overview.png",
      "bytes": 184488,
      "sha256": "f4e55297e9db792ea27a5ede51dc5ee05264321d1631cb277d1ed617e39f9756"
    },
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/logs/browser_lamp_outputs.png",
      "relative_path": "logs/browser_lamp_outputs.png",
      "bytes": 549150,
      "sha256": "d3983686f9d10137d9147f7b3428a3e4c15ac1d3bc737987568712e1354baecf"
    },
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/logs/browser_persimmon_outputs.png",
      "relative_path": "logs/browser_persimmon_outputs.png",
      "bytes": 309339,
      "sha256": "6305ffc4076475e7e84ce3db141fde7b4c5a4a5f3875a9b1f546fe5a2d0a642a"
    },
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/logs/browser_geometry.png",
      "relative_path": "logs/browser_geometry.png",
      "bytes": 233943,
      "sha256": "3cd423985ff445cb6daccfe207b251027efe3ecdf3cfecaff32ed5d209a82024"
    },
    {
      "path": "/research/cvl-eric_jht/particle_world/runs/integration/realwonder_pipeline_comparison_v1/logs/browser_mobile.png",
      "relative_path": "logs/browser_mobile.png",
      "bytes": 84930,
      "sha256": "c1d94022bb2e71fd8434a7c5d7d292aaa429fe4b0ae70797e3fb7c8f4dc4606e"
    }
  ]
}